It is the day before Yom Ha'Shoa, Holocaust Remembrance Day. I am in Jerusalem and as if on cue, the atmosphere assumes an eerie, ethereal quality. The sky descends on us, misty, yellow- green. It presses in upon us, hot, humid, oppressive. "Is it fog or pollution?" I ask and no one knows. Perhaps it is something else--an effect on the physical state of the country emanating, as a reflection, from the mood of the populace.
The air is thick with angels and accusing human fingers. Forgiveness is not on the agenda but blind eyes are false justifications. How quickly the victim becomes the mirror of his own enemy when given the chance. As usual, lives are reduced to numbers, statistics. This is why I hate the way Sho'a education is conducted.
Germans are depicted as extraordinarily more monstrous than the next human. To be cruel is human. To be animal is human. To lust for blood, to hate, to denigrate--is human.
Tell me you wouldn't do it, too--no, not that you don't "think" you would, but that you wouldn't.
This story is cliche. The winner writes history and the fine lines are drawn: between good and evil, between which person behind which gun represents the more righteous cause. What is forgotten or ignored is the fact that both sides hold a gun.
You tell me who is more civil--or not.
This is linked to Germany's problem, the societal struggle that is gevalt: history proposes a dichotomous problem at the least: that of being remembered and also of being forgotten. The consequences of either take their toll on the populations affected and that reckon with the history in question.
Yet too much dwelling creates insensitivity, lack-of risks a repetition. But humanity never learns anyway.
Question: can victims and their descendants ever overcome collective martyrdom? Can descendants of perpetrators ever overcome collective guilt? Is Germany's exercise in vergangenheitsgevaltigung valid? Healthy? Because of the Holocaust are Israel and Germany more linked than the US and Israel? Emotional interconnectedness is more binding than fiscal in terms of
lasting memory and the maintenance of the societal/cultural collective mythos.
Are Jews a nation of martyrs or a nation that celebrates life, like we claim? Ironic, considering Holocaust history, the way we treat it, and the current political/social situation here.
April 12, 2010
"It is interesting, darling, this human concern with grouping. Do you not all have the ultimate identity at the start?" asks the angel.
"It's part of our propensity for conflict. We tend towards hate. It is innate. So we create reasons and ways in which to do so. The easiest is defining ourselves and defining ourselves in opposition.
"It's too hard to figure out what we are but we're obsessed with it. So we give ourselves a positive label with a negative definition. To keep it up, destruction of the Other--the basest method of contact--usually satiates the need for definition. Unfortunately, the satisfaction is only temporary. Now, we tend towards hybridity. But we're still human--we're not this, we're not that. So it goes. Nothing changes, essentially."
"Is this a curse of corporeality? Your kineticism traps you in a cycle of destruction fed by...let us say...the biological instinct for the illogical, for hierarchy?"
"Perhaps it is a curse. But we escape it when we Scatter. It's actually very logical, though. Biology is all about hierarchy."
"No, Micha'el. But look how much you're missing, nonetheless."
At 10:00 a.m. this morning, on יום השועה (Yom Ha'Shoa), Holocaust Remembrance Day, the minute-long siren of commemoration sounded and the entire country stopped.
You tell me who is more civil--or not.
This is linked to Germany's problem, the societal struggle that is gevalt: history proposes a dichotomous problem at the least: that of being remembered and also of being forgotten. The consequences of either take their toll on the populations affected and that reckon with the history in question.
Yet too much dwelling creates insensitivity, lack-of risks a repetition. But humanity never learns anyway.
Question: can victims and their descendants ever overcome collective martyrdom? Can descendants of perpetrators ever overcome collective guilt? Is Germany's exercise in vergangenheitsgevaltigung valid? Healthy? Because of the Holocaust are Israel and Germany more linked than the US and Israel? Emotional interconnectedness is more binding than fiscal in terms of
Are Jews a nation of martyrs or a nation that celebrates life, like we claim? Ironic, considering Holocaust history, the way we treat it, and the current political/social situation here.
April 12, 2010
"It is interesting, darling, this human concern with grouping. Do you not all have the ultimate identity at the start?" asks the angel.
"It's part of our propensity for conflict. We tend towards hate. It is innate. So we create reasons and ways in which to do so. The easiest is defining ourselves and defining ourselves in opposition.
"It's too hard to figure out what we are but we're obsessed with it. So we give ourselves a positive label with a negative definition. To keep it up, destruction of the Other--the basest method of contact--usually satiates the need for definition. Unfortunately, the satisfaction is only temporary. Now, we tend towards hybridity. But we're still human--we're not this, we're not that. So it goes. Nothing changes, essentially."
"Is this a curse of corporeality? Your kineticism traps you in a cycle of destruction fed by...let us say...the biological instinct for the illogical, for hierarchy?"
"Perhaps it is a curse. But we escape it when we Scatter. It's actually very logical, though. Biology is all about hierarchy."
"You escape it when you Scatter. Yes. Potential realized and experienced. But I do not have qualms with my nature. I may not have potential. But I can never be Animal."
"No, Micha'el. But look how much you're missing, nonetheless."
At 10:00 a.m. this morning, on יום השועה (Yom Ha'Shoa), Holocaust Remembrance Day, the minute-long siren of commemoration sounded and the entire country stopped.
Cars in the middle of the road, people got out, stood still, hands clasped behind their backs. Not a breath stirred We all stood still. We give up one minute to remember all of those generations lost. The siren ends.
In perfect Israeli fashion, life resumes. The siren is only winding down and traffic starts rushing again. Within literally half a second, horns are honking. Welcome to Israel, Empire of Impatience. "We're going to die tomorrow, so we do things today," my friend tells me. "Don't waste time. You waste time mourning a future that hasn't happened yet and you miss today. Live to day." It's the old carpe diem again: try everything at least once. The past has been mourned enough. Take history in stride and make a new one.
April 13, 2010
When I was growing up, I attended Jewish summer sleep-away camp. Ramah Darom, in Clayton, Georgia. Common practice in the American Jewish camp world is importing Israelis as counselors and campers. One year, when I was either eleven or twelve, an Ethiopian counselor (we'll call her Z.) told us about her immigration to Israel. I'll paraphrase what she told us:
She came to Israel as a little girl from Ethiopia. Later, her parents told her what she couldn't comprehend as a child. Operation Moses, the Israeli operation begun in 1984 and continued in Operations Joshua and Solomon, brought about 36,000 Ethiopian Jews to Israel (for more information on this some sites are: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Juda ism/ejhist.html, and http://www.moia.gov.il/Moia_en/AboutIsrael/mivtzaMoshe.htm).
Z.'s parents were brought to Jerusalem, with thousands of others. Needless to say, modern-day Jerusalem looks nothing like the Jerusalem of Gold they all had in their minds. Jerusalem,

Wake up call: this is the Middle East and the holiest, most disputed city in the history of the world really struggles to retain that golden image. Shitting in the street is commonplace here. Holy water doesn't fall to be blessed, if it falls at all. It's counted as a blessing to have fallen.
In perfect Israeli fashion, life resumes. The siren is only winding down and traffic starts rushing again. Within literally half a second, horns are honking. Welcome to Israel, Empire of Impatience. "We're going to die tomorrow, so we do things today," my friend tells me. "Don't waste time. You waste time mourning a future that hasn't happened yet and you miss today. Live to day." It's the old carpe diem again: try everything at least once. The past has been mourned enough. Take history in stride and make a new one.
April 13, 2010
Walking down the street here for two seconds doesn't just exhibit the active, conscious creation of a new history but flaunts the shattering and reconstruction of deeply ingrained myths. For instance, "The Holy Land".
When I was growing up, I attended Jewish summer sleep-away camp. Ramah Darom, in Clayton, Georgia. Common practice in the American Jewish camp world is importing Israelis as counselors and campers. One year, when I was either eleven or twelve, an Ethiopian counselor (we'll call her Z.) told us about her immigration to Israel. I'll paraphrase what she told us:
She came to Israel as a little girl from Ethiopia. Later, her parents told her what she couldn't comprehend as a child. Operation Moses, the Israeli operation begun in 1984 and continued in Operations Joshua and Solomon, brought about 36,000 Ethiopian Jews to Israel (for more information on this some sites are: http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/Juda ism/ejhist.html, and http://www.moia.gov.il/Moia_en/AboutIsrael/mivtzaMoshe.htm).
Z.'s parents were brought to Jerusalem, with thousands of others. Needless to say, modern-day Jerusalem looks nothing like the Jerusalem of Gold they all had in their minds. Jerusalem,
ultimately, was a disappointment. Jerusalem stone was ubiquitous but not gold. And where was God? Some, surely, felt holiness, but according to Z. and her parents, most couldn't feel any sort of holy presence in the Holy City. Perhaps God was there, disguised as a man or two but no deafening voice thundered down from the heavens. What Z.'s parents found was an earthly city with just as much (or just as little) holiness as the next. So what is this "Holy Land"?
From this narrative, it is possible to say that it is only a desperate mythology that gilds hope in fool's gold at best.
Wake up call: this is the Middle East and the holiest, most disputed city in the history of the world really struggles to retain that golden image. Shitting in the street is commonplace here. Holy water doesn't fall to be blessed, if it falls at all. It's counted as a blessing to have fallen.
Despite the grime and the feces, the complex undercurrents of hate between the various sects of Jews and the overcurrents between Jews and Arabs, this city retains some inexplicable quality that I can only describe as holy. Despite the kipple, if you will, and despite the violence. (We are still not allowed in some sections of the Old City and every few weeks, we're told not to go near at all.) For what it's worth, Jerusalem exists on a scale teetering between a stressed, fragile calm and explosive violence. Holiness takes its toll but so does banality. Even so, there are more angels here than anywhere.